Abstract
This report examines the little-reported marketplace of small credit card issuers. The small issuer market is large indeed in terms of the number of players, with over six thousand institutions having credit card receivables less than $100 million on their balance sheets (between FDIC-insured banks and NCUA credit unions). Plus, there are perhaps an additional 2,000 institutions that have sold their portfolios and continue to function as agent banks. Given the number of prospect institutions, this is a competitive and desirable market for vendors providing various outsourcing services.
Topics explored include:
- While the U.S. card issuer market is highly concentrated among the top 10 issuers, over 8,000 direct issuers with less than $100 million in card assets remain active.
- Credit unions are twice as numerous as banks among direct small issuers.
- Credit card assets have decreased in importance to banks largely due to the growing importance of real estate lending.
- Small issuers can be segmented according to their strategic direction: committed issuers, portfolio sale/agent bank partners, and those re-evaluating their direction toward one of these approaches.
- The menu of outsourcing services available to support small issuers is extensive and helps deliver competitive products and services.
The study examines small issuer segments including committed direct issuers, agent banks, and those re-evaluating their credit card strategies. On the vendor front, segments of Processor/Outsourcers, Processor/Outsourcer/Portfolio Acquirers, Aggregators, and Specialty Portfolio Acquirers are described.
Ken Paterson, Director of the Credit Advisory Service at Mercator Advisory Group and the author of this report comments that, "to be charitable, credit cards are a difficult sphere in which to compete, and any issuer not in the top tier needs to be thinking about the optimal combination of in-house and outsourced capabilities that will deliver competitive product and a competitive return, while most importantly serving the needs and interests of the cardholders. This client view should not be ignored. Most small issuers are retail-focused organizations that want to offer credit cards as part of a client relationship. Delivering product capabilities and cardholder servicing that support their brand is typically a top-of-list concern."Table of Contents
TABLE OF FIGURES
Introduction
I. Small Issuers: By The Numbers
- Market Concentration
- Core Asset Or Afterthought?7
- The Big Picture (And By The Way, What Is A Small Issuer?)
- Sub-Segments: Small To Really Small
II. Motivations Of Small Issuers
- A Revolving Door? 18
- Small Issuer Qualitative Segments
III. Services for Small Issuers: An Embarrassment of Riches
- The Shopping List
- Vendor Segments: Categorization Is Hard- And Getting Harder
- Adapting to Issuer and Agent Needs
IV. Guessing The Future
TABLE OF FIGURES
- Figure 1: Card Assets Grow At Top 10 Issuers While Small Issuers Just Maintain
- Figure 2: Top 10 Issuers Gain Share
- Figure 3: Consumer Lending (ex. Mortgage) Declines In Importance At Small
Banks
- Figure 4: Credit Card Lending Declines In Importance At Small Banks
- Figure 5: Small Issuers, Large In Number
- Figure 6: Credit Unions Are More Likely To Be Direct Issuers
- Figure 7: De Novo Banks Create Potential Issuing Opportunities
- Figure 8: Small Issuers: $10B-$26B In Assets, Depending On Definition
- Figure 9: There Are More Credit Unions In The Game Across Most Small Issuer Segments
- Figure 10: Credit Unions Generate More Card Assets In All Segments But The Smallest
- Figure 11: In All Card Lending Tiers, Credit Unions Average Smaller Total Institutional Assets
- Figure 12: Card Assets Decline In Importance For Smaller Institutions
- Figure 13: Cyclicality Of Issuing Strategies: No Longer All Or Nothing
- Figure 14: A Qualitative Segmentation Of Small Issuers
- Figure 15: Small Issuer Outsourcing: Core Shopping List
- Figure 16: A Blurring Segmentation of Vendors
